The chief difference is that students are not assigned roles. They prepare for a group meeting by reading agreedupon pages, with the followup discussion led members of the group. We published a version of this manual intalking studentslistening teachers. Students have authentic conversations and is not rolebased. Resources for educators whether you already do studentled conferences or are interested in making a shift, this list includes a variety of goto examples, guides, tips, and forms to help launch or improve these meetings. If youre ready to start a book club, heres 40 of the best book club questions, for fiction. Assessing learning during studentled book clubs choice. Effects of literature discussion groups on reading. In my class, unprepared students read the pages in class before joining their group. This book details a framework for implementing studentled classroom discussions that improve student learning, motivation, and engagement across all levels. Last week, i wrote about accountability with book clubs, which you can read more about here. Ive been in a lot of book clubs, and i know its not always easy to get a conversation going on a book. This ongoing assignment had several pedagogical goals. Students then use the strategy to develop questions for a peer led book discussion.
Spider web discussions help students take ownership of learning. Oct 16, 2014 most discussions move too quickly, says riley, and great ideas get totally lost. Lively discussions give students a chance to ask questions and voice their opinions while building reading and analytical skills. Relationship qar strategy through a readaloud and question sort. Chunk books by having students read three to four chapters, then stop to hold a partner or small group student led discussion on that section. The sword thief by peter lerangis the 39 clues book 4. About this book introduce and cultivate studentled discussions about literary and informational material at any grade. Explicit instruction teach the process teach rituals and routines of effective group. These groups can be organized in a variety of ways. Literature circles and studentled book clubs are both instructional strategies that allow students choice, voice and motivation in reading. Four steps to deepen student discussions about math. Offer books that are at the comfort or independent reading levels of students. Book club teachers usually bring the whole class together after students have met in their small groups to allow them to share some of the most interesting ideas to grow out of the student led discussions.
Nov 18, 2019 the article included a description of student led discussions for an online course. Student led discussion strategies for whole class discussion. Literature circles and book clubs are a text discussion strategies that supports studentled facilitation and discussion in small groups. A book discussion group is a forum where readers can come together and talk about books and the reading experience. Creating third space through student led discussions and books with cultural content in a diverse classroom. Note the page number where this eventhappening takes place. We read and discuss fiction, nonfiction, short stories, and poetry and host live chats and interviews with leading authors. Student led academic discussions at metropolitan diploma plus duration. The responsibility for leading rotated among small groups of 3 or 4 students who were encouraged to master prezi to present their questions.
Observe and record data about students contributions and group behavior 4. There are adult groups, student led groups, motherdaughter groups, fatherson groups, and parentchild groups, to. Book clubs bring challenges in class management and assessment, but they can lead to improvements in students reading ability. Now, daniels and steineke team up to focus on one crucial element of the literature circle model. Ive found that the best book club discussion questions are ones that are openended and that get people to share their personal opinions. Students are introduced to the questionanswer relationship qar strategy through a readaloud and question sort. Keeping this in mind brings about the most meaningful lessons and discussions between my students and me. Studentled discussion groups appropriate student level. Gardeners theory of multiple intelligences is one way of separating a class into groups. The maze of bones by rick riordan the 39 clues book 2. In general, wholeclass discussions involve students in a wider community of readers and allow them to benefit from the work of all their. During book club discussions, students refer to their notes on these questions and their. A study investigated the development of theme as five fifthgrade students read childrens literature, recorded their responses in logs, and discussed their ideas in small, student led peer groups. Lets first identify some characteristics of student led conversations with book clubs.
Kelly ate with the other lead actors and talked about the play. How do i promote rich conversations about books, videos, and other media. Describe something that happened in your book that you really want to discuss during book club. Extended discussion of text meaning and interpretation. Minilessons for literature circles by harvey daniels. Nonlibrarians are welcome to join the group as well. You can read more about her development of the model in chapter 1 of her 2017 ascd book. If other students are getting antsy, choose one of your alwaysready students to share, then loop back to the student who needed time with the text. Recognize and evaluate effective studentled discussions. They start with students arriving to class having read a shared text. To show everyone what a meaningful discussion looks like, place a group of four or five students on center stage in front of the room. Some book scrutiny processes are designed so that students are directly involved every time others not all.
Use specific passages from the book as evidence for your ideas. This might be done by requiring students to bring their books to a scrutiny session and this is how book looks are always done. By creating roles within each literature circle or book club group and specific tasks for the group to accomplish during their text discussion time, teachers can modify the work to make it more student centered. The instructor is available to answer questions and guide the discussion if necessary, but the emphasis is on the exchange of student. Each of you will have an opportunity to work in pairs and lead class discussion for 30 minutes. Sitting in front of the rest of the class, the student responds to classmates questions while staying in character in that role. Creating third space through studentled discussions and books with cultural content in a diverse classroom. One student assumes the role of a book character, significant figure in history, or concept such as a tornado, an animal, or the titanic. Students then use the strategy to develop questions for a peerled book discussion. Youll need to get the class involved and attempt to create a dynamic discussion. The black circle by patrick carman the 39 clues book 6. Not all mathematical discussions have the same aim or should be led in the same way. One false note by gordon korman the 39 clues book 3. Spider web discussions help students take ownership of.
Literature circles and book clubs are a text discussion strategies that supports student led facilitation and discussion in small groups. Nonlibrarians are welcome to join the group as well, to comment or. The article included a description of student led discussions for an online course. While they have many benefits, student led discussions often create unintended consequences that inhibit their effectiveness. Nancy steinekes reading and writing together showed how a teacher can nurture friendship and collaboration among young readers. Afterschool training toolkit book discussion groups and. Consider the consequences of being unprepared for a book discussion. Today, i am writing specifically about student led conversations in book clubs. Holding collaborative chats about differentiated books. Litcourse 3 has a good discussion of close reading. Student led book clubs have the same goals as literature circles. Understand your role as the teacher when students are leading their own discussions. Studentled conversations in book clubs inspire me asap.
Student led discussion formats allow for increased student responsibility and more room for student voices, and they may lead to more complex responses from students, the valuing of multiple viewpoints, and more engaged discussions almasci et al. Invite them to discuss a story or several chapters in a book. Give students enough time to flip through and find just the right piece of evidence. Tell students the reading and writing choices they will have after they complete a discussion and journal work. Several studies advocate a mixed gender grouping since one dominating student can control the whole discussion. Mar 06, 2018 after years of experimentation with studentled discussions, ive honed three approaches that have made almost all conversations in my classroom both complex and enlightening. Aug 21, 2017 ive been in a lot of book clubs, and i know its not always easy to get a conversation going on a book. A small group of students created 34 activities and related discussions to enhance the weeks lesson. Book discussion groups and literature circles use stories to engage students in discussions about what theyre reading. There are adult groups, studentled groups, motherdaughter groups, fatherson groups, and parentchild groups, to name just a few. Book discussion groups home libguides at american library. Take notes or mark passages that strike youpassages you find significant, funny, or insightful. The big list of class discussion strategies cult of pedagogy. Decide on the number of student led book discussions you will have each week.
Most discussions move too quickly, says riley, and great ideas get totally lost. Book club is a curriculum developed with students and teachers in mind to create studentled discussions in the classroom. In each strategy, students select books they wish to read with a group of their peers. Jan 11, 2018 it was through her experience with the harkness method that wiggins discovered and embraced the power of student led discussions.
Heterogeneous grouping can include gender, race, or ability. I can check for comprehension around a book or determine how well a student has been using a skill we are working on. Literature circles and book clubs betterlesson coaching. See more ideas about teaching, teaching reading, school reading. The book also includes links to authentic video of students engaged in discussions. When students love books, they cant put them down and cant resist talking about them. I wanted this discussion guide to be a resource for students who were struggling to keep the conversation going, but it is useful as a first step for all of them. Student led discussions in small groups can be another solution for students who are hesitant to engage in wholeclassroom discussions. Beyond the grave by jude watson the 39 clues book 5. A place where all goodreads members can work together to improve the goodreads book catalog. When students are in charge of discussing books they selected and can read, motivation and engagement soar. This is a literary analysis technique called close reading.
Establish core instructional elements that students need to engage in rich discussions about content. Practice listening to others courteously by participating in discussions. Recognize and evaluate effective student led discussions. In student led discussions, author sandi novak offers you the resources you need to develop meaningful student led conversations about text and media across the content areas. Use leveled books in student led discussions middleweb. What makes an effective online course, sparked some lively discussion on our online teaching listserv. Fortunately, there are solutions that can enable students to take ownership of academic conversations and facilitate discussions across classroom settings. Three approaches to guiding your students to take ownership over their discussions of shared texts. The choice, autonomy, selfdirection, motivation and authenticity of student led book clubs make my teacher heart smile. Decide on the number of studentled book discussions you will have each week. Harvey daniels literature circles introduced tens of thousands of teachers to the power of student led book discussions. Common core facilitating studentled discussions georgia. How to discuss books litlovers book club recommendations. The number will change and depend on other reading experiences that you offer students.
The difference between a student led discussion and a socratic seminar. A powerful form of thinking and communicating, studentled conversations can last from five to 15 minutes and bring social interactions to students learning. Minilessons for literature circles by harvey smokey. It should be an essential questionone that will elicit varied or even polarized responses. A powerful form of thinking and communicating, student led conversations can last from five to 15 minutes and bring social interactions to students learning. As she shifted from lecturebased teaching to more facilitated learning, she developed what she now calls spider web discussion. The five students met together as one group over the course of 5 weeks as they read historical fiction focused on japan during world war ii. A web resource for educators interested in student led book discussion groups, featuring book recommendations, classroom management ideas, links to related sites and organizations, and news of relevant publications and events.
Joellen coryell, adult, professional, and community education. Chunk books by having students read three to four chapters, then stop to hold a partner or small group studentled discussion on that section. There are several ways you can lead class discussion. By creating roles within each literature circle or book club group and specific tasks for the group to accomplish during their text discussion time, teachers can modify the work to make it more studentcentered. At the beginning of class, share a single, openended question about the text. Assessing learning during studentled book clubs choice literacy. Have multiple copies of documents related to that question literary criticism, encyclopedia entries, opeds. In addition to providing a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively, she includes advice for how to. It was through her experience with the harkness method that wiggins discovered and embraced the power of student led discussions. A web resource for educators interested in student led book discussion groups, featuring. Aug 08, 2019 a book discussion group is a forum where readers can come together and talk about books and the reading experience. Feb 03, 2017 3 tips for running successful student led book clubs have you always wanted to run book clubs in your classroom, but youre just not sure how to set them up, keep your readers accountable, or get your students reading, writing and talking deeply about books. Student led discussion groups these types of small groups are led by a student and meant to stimulate discussion on a given topic.
684 1159 82 1415 531 1502 1170 521 1672 527 1418 1396 372 1261 939 1401 501 1179 503 408 52 1095 1241 1237 286 969 323 440 1384 979